FIFA 23 vs FC 24: What Are Fan Reactions?

Launched at the end of September 2023, EA Sports FC 24 disappointed millions of football enthusiasts with numerous familiar issues such as bugs, gameplay problems, glitches, and even the removal of familiar features. These issues provoked a strong negative reaction from a large number of EA players, especially FIFA 23 fans. Although problems are common in games, the fan reaction to EA FC 24 is perhaps one of the most eye-opening.

In this article, we'll explore the fan reactions to FIFA 23 vs. FC 24. However, before delving into the dire state of FC 24, it's important to acknowledge that the situation has reached an unacceptable level.

“It is by far the most pay-to-win edition I’ve seen! It's like I'm investing in betting. Not to mention the trash gameplay! EA really messed this one up!,” said an EA Sports FC 24 player.

“Terrible, it’s sad how they destroy a great game like FIFA 23. The defence player’s AI is awful. This is my last game of the franchise.,” rated another fan.

Is AE FC 24 worse than FIFA?

Since its official release date, EA FC 24 has undergone up to FIVE Title Updates. That averages out to approximately one Title Update per week. To be honest, no game title should ever necessitate so many patches in such rapid succession. In comparison, within the same timeframe last year, EA issued only THREE Title Updates for FIFA 23. While that may still seem substantial for a newly released game, it highlights the severity of FC 24's issues.

While it's worth noting that EA deserves some credit for being responsive to feedback and taking prompt action to address its new game’s issues, we cannot bother with the broader perspective. The point is that fans, and even EA themselves, should not have encountered so many issues right from the start. Many players feel that the developers did not adequately test and trial the game prior to its launch! Right, EA can push out as many patches as they want, but this significant issue should not arise when players are investing £50 - £100 in their product.

While Title Updates continue to roll out and the FC 24 controversy persists, EA appears to be conveniently focusing on the future in an attempt to maintain positivity. However, it has been half a year, and did their attempts yield the desired results?

EA Sports FC 24 & FIFA 23 Were Both Reviews Bombed

Now, let's see what users say about FC 24 and FIFA 24 on prominent gaming platforms.

EA Sports' FC 24 holds a user rating of merely 2.2 on Metacritic, significantly lower than the critic score of 76 for the PS5 version. User reviews emphasize a lot of issues, with the lack of differentiation from previous games in the EA Sports FC 24 franchise being a major point of contention. Other than that, as we noted, some players have encountered a wide range of in-game bugs, while others have raised concerns about AI, unrealistic gameplay, physics, etc.

“ABSOLUTE TRASH. EVERYTHING ABOUT IT!! I AM BEGGING YOU SAVE YOUR MONEY OR BUY AN ACTUALLY NICE GAME. The referee decisions, the gameplay, bugs everything is horrible please run awayyyy!!!,” a player claimed.

On Steam, EA Sports FC 24 receives a mixed overall rating from users, with only 55% of the user reviews being positive. Players express frustration with the prevalence of in-game bugs and glitches, along with notable optimization issues. Furthermore, many users point out that FC 24 closely resembles FIFA 23 despite the different name, leading to disappointment in their purchase decision.

This pattern of negative feedback is not new to the FIFA series, as previous entries have also faced review bombing. For instance, FIFA 23 received a low rating of just 2.5 on Metacritic upon its launch (now 3.3), indicating a similar trend of critical backlash persists with the release of EA Sports FC 24. It will be intriguing to observe how the user score fluctuates as more fans have the opportunity to experience the game.

Compliments for EA FC 24

Besides criticism, many players turn out to love the FIFA 23’s successor. Here are some ratings:

“Not sure what people are complaining about here. The graphics are great, the games can be intense, especially on a harder level, the Champions League is perfectly realistic, and I love playing with my favourite team. The menu also does not lag for me, it's not perfect but pretty good.”

“FC 24 is a game that stands out for its impressive technical and visual section. The graphics are of high quality, with detailed textures, faces, and facial expressions. The stadium atmosphere is very well done, and the new narrations by Miguel Ángel Román and DJMario are equally noticeable. I've seen some very curious celebrations from the stands, probably bugs, but it's very situational. Recommended (Minus UT, that mode is Pay-to-win).”

Final Words

Overall, AE Sports FC 24 receives negative reviews from players compared to its predecessor. Nonetheless, admit it, many players still appreciate the game. Looking ahead, we hope that the developers will take heed of user feedback and work towards enhancing the user experience to make the games better for all football fans.

>>> Read more: The Best FIFA Gamers To Follow Right Now