Truly frightening horror games are rare, but Silent Hill stood out as one of the initial franchises to haunt players with its psychological terror, stemming from compelling storylines and innovative creature designs in each installment. The early games remain timeless classics, continuously captivating new generations of gamers.
Currently, the series is on hold following the cancellation of Silent Hills, an anticipated project featuring renowned horror director Guillermo del Toro and Metal Gear creator Hideo Kojima. While a revival seems distant, let's seize this chance to reflect on the series by ranking all the games from the least impressive to the best Silent Hill game.
1. Silent Hill 2
Silent Hill 2 not only pushed the survival horror genre to unprecedented levels but also raised the entire medium to greater heights. Its visuals were groundbreaking, offering a level of realism unseen before, and the story, following James Sunderland's quest for his deceased wife, is an intensely personal and terrifying exploration of guilt.
In a way, this discomfort is deliberate, permeating the game from its narrative implications to its unsettling creature designs. While undeniably a phenomenal experience, it might be overwhelming for certain players. It is precisely this challenging and unwavering atmosphere that crowns Silent Hill 2 as the franchise's standout game.
Silent Hill 2: Restless Dreams appears smoother on the Xbox, but certain effects suffer a downgrade. According to John Linneman from Digital Foundry, the Xbox version has inferior fog effects, CG cinematics reduced from 60 frames per second to 30, and lower audio quality.
The PC release shares similar problems, but fan patches do address some issues. In the end, it's recommended to opt for the PS2 version.
2. Silent Hill
The initial Silent Hill remains a captivating game, worth playing regardless of one's age. Even with outdated graphics, if tension is skillfully crafted, it can still terrify players, a quality Silent Hill possesses, haunting gamers even two decades after its launch.
Diverging from other survival horror titles on the PS1, such as Resident Evil, Silent Hill is unique for its fully realized 3D environment. Despite the severely restricted draw distance, it's remarkable how the developers managed to create such an environment on Sony's inaugural console.
3. Silent Hill 3
The third installment in the series faced high expectations, although it doesn't quite reach the level set by Silent Hill 2. Despite this, Cheryl Mason's harrowing adventure successfully maintains the franchise's reputation.
The game's graphics stretched the boundaries of what people believed the PS2 could achieve, and the storyline, while not as psychological as its forerunner, was still engaging. Fans' main grievance centered around the absence of innovative gameplay. Yet, considering the existing formula's success, the question arises: why change something drastically if it's already effective?
4. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
The primary appeal of Shattered Memories lay in the quizzes and assessments conducted in a doctor's office between chapters. The player's responses and performance in these segments influenced the subsequent chapter.
This feature received significant acclaim, as did the game's effective use of the Nintendo Wii's motion controls—a feat often elusive for many third-party developers. Due to disappointing sales, the game was ported to PS2 and PSP, eliminating the motion controls but retaining the rest of the experience.
5. Silent Hill: Origins
The prequel to the initial game was notable for being the first instance where a game directly linked to another's events. Adapting well-known franchises to Sony's first handheld posed challenges, especially given the PSP's single analog stick. Despite this limitation, Origins made significant efforts to adapt to the platform.
Many reviewers expressed satisfaction with how the game translated onto the portable device, although some critiques were aimed at the combat system. However, the story received widespread acclaim, particularly among series enthusiasts, thanks to its connections with the original entry.
6. Silent Hill 4: The Room
The fourth installment in the series marked a significant departure. Despite carrying the franchise's name, it doesn't unfold in the titular town. Moreover, gameplay emphasizes combat over puzzle-solving.
However, it shouldn't be perceived as a pure action game, as the world remains filled with tension and unease. This shift in focus received mixed reactions, with some appreciating the change and others disliking it. While it may not be the most acclaimed PS2 entry, it still offers a decent option for horror gaming on the console.
7. Silent Hill: Homecoming
Silent Hill: Homecoming marked Double Helix Games' debut project and was the initial mainline entry in the franchise developed by a western studio. The overall reception was generally favorable.
While it didn't achieve outstanding scores, it performed well enough to demonstrate that a non-Japanese developer could effectively manage the franchise. Additionally, it was the first installment to introduce a fully controllable camera. Certain violent scenes necessitated edits, causing delays in the game's release in specific regions.
8. Silent Hill: Downpour
Following a few entries that deviated slightly from the series' core, Downpour made an attempt to reclaim the essence of the classics that made them iconic. Many reviewers recognized this effort, applauding the game's more expansive areas that encouraged exploration. However, criticisms were raised regarding other aspects of its design, such as combat, enemies, and overall performance.
Although it succeeded in some aspects, it fell short where the original games had excelled, especially in terms of technical performance. Silent Hill 2 and 3, in particular, were exceptionally well-crafted games in this regard.
9. Silent Hill: Book Of Memories
Had Book of Memories not been associated with the Silent Hill franchise, it might not have achieved as much success. A dungeon crawler for the PS Vita was not what fans anticipated from the survival horror series. While some players appreciated the references to the franchise's history, many found the gameplay lacking compared to other contemporary titles in the genre.
Additionally, it stands as the longest game in the Silent Hill series, demanding players to brace themselves for a lengthy experience if they choose to dive in. Among popular franchises spanning over two decades, the weakest entry in the series isn't the worst choice one could make. Fortunately, the series improves significantly from this point onward.
>>> Read more: 6 Best Medieval RPGs To Play In 2023
Comments